Pet Circle vs Petbarn — which Australian pet retailer is actually cheaper?
By Dogthings Editorial · Updated 2026-04-23
Affiliate disclosure: Some links on this page earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and services we'd use with our own dogs.
Pet Circle and Petbarn between them dominate Australian pet retail. Choosing the wrong one could cost you $200–500 a year on food alone for a large dog. Here's the side-by-side on price, range, and actual delivery experience.
Quick verdict
- Pick Pet Circle for almost everything online — cheaper, wider range, autoship saves another 5%.
- Pick Petbarn if you need click & collect same-day, or if the VIP Pet program math works for your purchase volume.
Side-by-side
| Feature | Pet Circle | Petbarn |
|---|---|---|
| Range | ~8,000 SKUs | ~5,000 SKUs online |
| Physical stores | None | 200+ nationally |
| Click & collect | No | Yes — often same-day |
| Free shipping | Over $49 | Over $79 (online) |
| Typical premium kibble price (15kg Royal Canin) | $175–195 | $195–215 |
| Autoship / recurring discount | 5% off recurring orders | 10% off first auto-delivery, 5% after |
| Loyalty program | Pet Circle Club (free) | VIP Pet (free) + VIP Pet Pals ($50/yr) |
| In-store vet | No | Greencross Vets co-located at many stores |
| In-store grooming | No | Most stores |
Price comparison — real numbers
Checked 15 common products across both retailers in April 2026. Pet Circle came out cheaper on 13 of 15, by an average of 8–12%. The two items where Petbarn was cheaper or equal: Greenies dental treats (sale-dependent) and Advance kibble on Petbarn's frequent 20%-off promos.
Where Pet Circle consistently wins
- Premium kibble (Ziwi, Acana, Orijen, Royal Canin) — 10–15% cheaper
- Prescription diets (Hill's Prescription, Royal Canin Veterinary) — slightly cheaper, stocks all variants
- Bulk consumables (puppy pads, wet food cartons, treats) — bigger packs, lower per-unit price
- Autoship combined with 5% repeat-customer discount stacks over time
Where Petbarn is worth using
- Urgent supplies — click & collect in 1–2 hours beats 1–2 day shipping
- In-store consultations — staff can recommend food, show you product sizes in person
- VIP Pet Pals paid tier — $50/year membership offering 10% off everything, free grooming adds, priority vet booking. Worth it if you spend $1,000+/year.
- Greencross Vets integration — convenient if you use the vet already
What about Budget Pet Products?
A third option — not a head-to-head with these two, but worth knowing. Budget Pet Products is the cheapest in Australia on parasite prevention (Nexgard Spectra, Simparica, Bravecto) — consistently 15–25% below Pet Circle and Petbarn. Smaller range on food, plain website, real savings.
Our recommendation
Default to Pet Circle for all dog food and consumables — autoship a 15kg bag of your dog's regular food every 6–8 weeks, never run out, and save 5% forever.
Use Petbarn when you need click & collect same-day, or if a store is conveniently placed on your weekly routine.